st. anger sucks

topic posted Sun, February 1, 2004 - 7:02 PM by  Suzy
i really didnt like the st. anger cd. it wasnt the old metallica. but i still love metallica though.
posted by:
Suzy
Detroit
  • Re: st. anger sucks

    Wed, February 11, 2004 - 10:27 PM
    I AGREE! I am a die hard MetallicA fan and will continue to go see their shows (see all my pics in the photo album of this tribe!). But St. Anger isn't a good album. It sounded pretty good live, but the mixing and production of it sounds like shit. Lars sounds like he's banging on metal trash cans. I like the first two songs on the album and that's about it. Glad to see there are other Met fans out there who feel the same way I do about the album.
    • Re: st. anger sucks

      Thu, February 12, 2004 - 12:39 PM
      every metallica fan that ive talked to agrees with me on this...
      • Re: st. anger sucks

        Fri, March 12, 2004 - 10:06 PM
        St. Anger is definately not one of my favorite albums, but I do not think it sucks. I think Metallica fans just have such a high standard, and if the album isn't perfect, then fans are disappointed. It is like when I root for my Kentucky Wildcat's. If they don't win a NCAA title in basketball, then the whole state wants to axe the coach.

        Sweet Amber is my favorite song off the Album.
        • Re: st. anger sucks

          Sun, March 14, 2004 - 3:25 PM
          I'm right with you guys all!!! there going on tour!!! I really wanna go to ther concert
          • Re: st. anger sucks

            Tue, April 20, 2004 - 1:15 AM
            I'm not too fond of the music on St. Anger (ie the vile sound of lars's snare, the lack of solos...), however I can appreciate some things about the album. Hetfield lays down the anger that he's expressing on the album really well.

            But anyway, I hear they've been kickin fucking ass on tour. They've been playing all the good stuff...

            Anyone see them lately?
            • Re: st. anger sucks

              Wed, April 21, 2004 - 11:34 AM
              They are coming to Louisville on the 28th, which is about an hour away, but it is on a Wednesday. Why can't they come on a day when I don't have an 8am final class the next day.

              I will probably go see them in Columbus in September. Hope they aren't worn out by then.
              • Re: st. anger sucks

                Mon, May 17, 2004 - 9:52 PM
                I personally think that the CD isn't their best, But it's being compared to their previous albums, which a lot would be hard to rival by anyone. But you also have to consider what they've been going through. Jason Newsted left in 2001, and it wasn't until spring of 2002 that they started working on St. Anger, and that was with their producer, Bob Rock, as the bassist. And all this was only after James Hetfield had gone through rehab. And during that time, Lars and Kirk also had plenty of time to think and plenty of things to think about, to re-evaluate themselves, etc. So this CD is the product of losing a member of the band, rehab, and countless hours of self-reflection. And they only picked up Robert Trujillo in the process of making St. Anger.
                So I agree with you guys, that this isn't their best CD that they've put out... BUT, considering their path to this album, much respect is in order. "I have to give props where they due!" haha...
                Oh and, hasn't Metallica been around for, what... 23 years now?? ... much respect....
                So what do you guys think?
  • Unsu...
     

    Re: st. anger sucks

    Thu, September 22, 2005 - 12:58 PM
    couldn't agree more this album sucks it's not the same old metallica but there still my favorite
  • Re: st. anger sucks

    Tue, January 30, 2007 - 9:06 PM
    yea st anger sucked shit, it was a real disappointment (where are the grinding solos man???!!!) hopefully their new album will be heading back towards their old stuff.
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: st. anger sucks

      Fri, February 2, 2007 - 11:43 PM
      Yeah everyone can say what they want, I like St.Anger its a recovery album.....respect for Metallica. Its been out now for 4 years and the new album comes out this year. St.Anger sold....its done.....grab a tissue and go cry kid.
      • Unsu...
         

        Re: st. anger sucks

        Sat, February 3, 2007 - 8:50 AM
        I don't get why people won't let James grow up.
        • Unsu...
           

          Re: st. anger sucks

          Sun, February 4, 2007 - 2:33 AM
          Yeah you rock, I also think James had decided to stay healthy.
          Have you seen the movie Some Kind Of Monster, after I saw that and what James and Metallica went through....I got great respect for them. The most easy thing to do what split up, but fuck no we got Metallica back......Rock On Masters Of Metal

          Metal Up Your Ass!!!!!!!
          • Unsu...
             

            Re: st. anger sucks

            Sun, February 4, 2007 - 11:15 AM
            I have always liked that pesky little Lars is so driven and self-aware, and it's good to see James finally take care of himself and his family and be a bit introspective. The guy lost his mom as a teenager and he drowned himself in music and booze. He tempers the workaholic Lars and I see him as more of an intellectual equal with Lars now. I never even liked James, the man, very much before this album. He always seemed like some macho posturing dick--but he was a great lyricist and has one of the greatest voices. Now I know there is something underneath that. I have a great respect for James. He took a huge risk to show his vulnerability on St. Anger and while it's not their best album, if you're a fan, you look at their development as men in the context of their music. They have truly grown up and we, as fans, have to let them.

            I appreciate that James was able to finally stand up for himself as an adult. Even if he did make the band wait and it changed the whole tone of their last record. So what? I don't want to them to be what they were in 1988.
  • Re: st. anger sucks

    Tue, March 20, 2007 - 3:50 AM
    yup everyone is right, it does suck in many ways. i think its the only metallica album where i liked 2 songs only. st. anger and frantic. the rest are just trash.

Recent topics in "Metallica"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Veteran Metal Pioneer, Bob Muldowney, dies at 44 ( and sorry ... Unsubscribed 0 January 22, 2008
Oldschool = the best shit!!!! Dang 0 January 13, 2008
New Metallica Song Tim 3 January 21, 2007
Rick Rubin to produce new album Dan 2 September 25, 2006
Any Metclub members here? Desi 1 July 19, 2006